Why Leaders Don’t Get the Marketing Results They Want
- Lyanne Campbell
- Jul 5
- 5 min read
Leaders don't get the results of the marketing they wish they had.
They get the results of the marketing they choose to support.
I've sat in enough of these meetings to know it's not an exception. It's a pattern.
Business is steady. Referrals are coming in. And somewhere in the room, it gets said out loud.
"We don't need to be out in market right now. Word of mouth is doing the job."
What's really being said is this: we're choosing not to support marketing, and we're comfortable with whatever comes from that choice.
That makes it sound like patience. It is not. It is a decision.
If this is a conversation your leadership team needs to have, let’s talk.
I help credit unions connect marketing decisions to the goals the Board and Leadership say matter.
The results you have are already the results of a choice
That word of mouth carrying you right now didn't show up on its own. It's the outcome of decisions made a year or two ago. Someone chose to fund visibility, staff time, and consistency, and the trust built from that is what's helping to land referrals today.
So when leadership pulls support now, they're not stepping back from a system that runs itself. They're choosing the next set of results too. It just won't show up on this quarter's numbers. It shows up later, when the account that you’ve been drawing from runs empty.
It's not "will this cost us." It's "we've already chosen that it will, we just delayed the impact."
Wanting growth and choosing against it in the same breath
Here's where it gets uncomfortable, and I say that with respect, because I've watched good leaders do exactly this.
"We really want to grow this area next year, we just don't have the bandwidth to take anything on right now."
Then a plan lands on the desk, tied to that exact goal, and it gets shelved. Not because it's weak. Because it asks for something right now. Time. Budget. A decision with a name attached to it.
Wanting something costs nothing. Choosing to support it costs a visible amount, today.
When a leader keeps choosing against the plan while saying they want the outcome, the gap between the two isn't a mystery. It's the answer.
Ask yourself plainly. When a plan lands on your desk tied to a goal you said mattered, what do you do with it? That tells you more than any strategy session will.
This isn't a case for campaigning on something you can't deliver
I want to be clear about where this doesn't apply.
If you don't have the capacity to follow through on a product or service, I wouldn't tell you to promote it either. Choosing not to overpromise is still a choice worth making, and a good one.
But there's a difference between campaigning on something you can't support and supporting the trust that got you here in the first place. In the credit union space, trust is the product. Members aren't shopping for the shiniest new thing most of the time. They're watching for who shows up consistently and who has their back when it counts. That kind of trust isn't built through a single campaign. It's built through what you choose to keep showing up for, month after month.
Going quiet because business feels good right now is choosing to stop investing in the very thing that made it feel good.
"We're already doing something" isn't the same as choosing with intent
I'll meet you halfway here.
"We're not ignoring marketing, we're still posting on social."
If your worry is that marketing shouldn't get money just to say something is happening, I agree with you. One platform, running with no structure and no tie to what the organization is trying to achieve, is still a choice.
It just produces the result of that choice: activity without impact, and a line item that looks like a cost because it is one.
Random effort and no effort often land in the same place: neither is tied to a goal, so neither earns its keep.
The choice that moves things is the one tied to intent. A single channel, run with structure and pointed at a real business goal, will outperform five channels running on autopilot every time.
Why this reframe helps you, not just your marketing team
It's tempting to hear all this as pressure. I'd push back on that.
Once you accept that results come from what you choose to support, you get something back: control.
You're no longer at the mercy of the market, the competition, or whatever word of mouth decides to do this quarter. The next set of results is yours to shape, because you know exactly which lever produces it.
That's a far more confident place to lead from than hoping the good run continues.
Sit with this before your next planning meeting
Look at the results you have right now. Which of them are you crediting to luck or timing? Is this closer to the end of its life cycle for a choice made a while back?
The next time a plan lands on your desk tied to a goal you've said out loud you care about, what will you choose to do with it?
If your team disappeared from view for the next twelve months, what result would that choice produce? Are you comfortable owning that?
Where have you been wanting an outcome while quietly choosing against the thing that gets you there?
The upside is this. If the results are shaped by what you support, you can choose differently starting today.
Keep on being amazing,
Lyanne
Marketing shouldn’t feel like guesswork.
If you’re tired of feeling invisible in your organization, you’re in the right place. My goal is to help you create a clear, strategic marketing presence that works - so you can stop scrambling and start leading.
📩 Want first access to my best marketing insights? Subscribe to the TLC (Tip. Learn. Connect.) Newsletter and get straight-to-the-point strategies delivered to your inbox. Get the one that’s right for you:
Need hands-on help? As a nationally recognized marketing strategist and Chartered Marketer, I’ve helped businesses transform their marketing from a cost center to a revenue driver. Whether you’re looking for marketing guidance, to be part of a marketing community, or to get in on a mastermind group, I’d love to connect. Let’s make your marketing work smarter, not harder.
To your success,
Lyanne
Comments